s2Member vs Easy Digital Downloads or Restrict Content Pro

Just wondering, has anyone who uses s2Member not so much for selling memberships but more as a way to grant users access to downloadable files ever tried the Easy Digital Downloads plugin? I’m looking into EDD right now as a possible replacement for s2Member and was wondering if anyone has any experience with it.

Or perhaps someone has experience with Restrict Content Pro, another plugin made by the same company that makes Easy Digital Downloads. Unlike s2Member, both of these plugins look like they are in active development. But are either of them comparable to s2Member?