Thanks Tim but it’s a little too complex to run it down to a simplistic site and it won’t help - one is better off, IMHO, working within the structure etc and taking each point in turn. I have troubleshooted this and worked it out. It’s a shame S2 Member won’t support any of us here because some the issues we discuss might be worth them considering for other troubleshooting upgrades etc. The issue was the selected option in Member Profile Modifications. The commentrary says it all “Recommended setting (Yes). Note: When this is set to (Yes), s2Member will take an initiative to further safeguard ALL /wp-admin/ areas of your installation; not just the Default Profile Panel.”
On another note. In exploring front end customisation - as you suggested - I didn’t really find a plugin that did the job. It’s not worth spending the money on a premium plugin with the added options until one knows it will work the way one wants and one doesn’t necessarily have that option with the unpaid versions. Instead, I preferred to look at using a backend solution - let’s face it most of us want to go front end because the backend is scary for contributors and we don’t want them meddling in stuff they shouldn’t. So WP Admin UI Customize is a significant step forward…
Thanks for your input Tim.